By Josh Windsor
Senior Caves Manager, Murray’s Cheese, New York City
October 27, 2026
From: Entertaining 2026
The modern cheese counter has become a vibrant forum for culinary curiosity and increasingly, for questions rooted in scientific understanding and ethical considerations. Among the most frequent inquiries this year, the subject of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) has regularly surfaced, often leading to a fascinating, if sometimes complex, discussion. Customers are keen to ascertain if their beloved cheese contains GMOs, and a significant portion of their questions revolve around a single, crucial ingredient: rennet.
The concise and reassuring answer, which we proudly offer, is that all cheese found in our cases, and indeed the vast majority of cheese commercially available, is entirely free of GMOs. This categorical assurance, however, bel belies a deeper story involving cutting-edge biotechnology, meticulous regulation, and the very essence of how milk transforms into cheese. To truly understand this, we must delve into the intricate world of rennet and the scientific innovations that have shaped modern cheesemaking.
The Regulatory Lens: Defining GMOs in Food
In the United States, the oversight of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) is a collaborative effort, jointly managed by three federal agencies: the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the Department of Agriculture (USDA), and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Each plays a distinct role in ensuring the safety and appropriate use of biotechnology in our food system. The FDA, in particular, holds the primary responsibility for determining whether a GMO or a GMO-derived ingredient is safe for human consumption.
Currently, the FDA has approved ten species of genetically edited plants and two species of genetically engineered animals for human consumption. This list includes staples like corn and soybeans, fruits such as papayas, and protein sources like pigs and salmon. A critical point for cheese enthusiasts is that none of the species on this approved list are direct ingredients in cheesemaking, nor are they animals that produce the milk from which cheese is traditionally made. Dairy cattle, goats, and sheep, for instance, are not genetically engineered organisms in the context of commercial milk production for cheese.
So, if cheese itself and the milk it’s made from are unequivocally not GMOs, why does the association persist? The answer, as many discerning customers instinctively surmise, lies in one specific and indispensable ingredient: rennet. The story of rennet is a compelling narrative of ancient tradition meeting modern science, highlighting how advanced biotechnology can enhance traditional processes without altering the fundamental nature of the final product.
Rennet: The Indispensable Catalyst of Cheesemaking
At its core, rennet is any enzyme or combination of enzymes used to coagulate the caseins—the primary proteins—in milk, initiating the crucial transformation from liquid milk into a firm-bodied curd, the foundation of all cheese. Enzymes are biological catalysts, meaning they accelerate specific chemical reactions without being consumed in the process. They are the molecular workhorses of all living organisms, overwhelmingly composed of proteins, each with a highly specific function.
The instructions for creating every protein within a living cell are meticulously encoded in its DNA. For a cell to synthesize a particular protein, an enzyme called transcriptase navigates along a specific segment of DNA, known as a gene. It reads these instructions and transcribes them into another messenger molecule: RNA. This RNA molecule then detaches and travels to another cellular component, the ribosome, which acts as a protein factory. The ribosome reads the RNA instructions and, using amino acids as building blocks, synthesizes the specific protein. This fundamental, unidirectional flow of genetic information—from DNA to RNA to protein—is famously known as the central dogma of molecular biology.
Consequently, all rennet, regardless of its source, is ultimately derived from a living organism whose DNA contains the genes that encode the instructions for producing these vital enzymes. This holds true for cardosin, one of the enzymes found in the cardoon thistle, which has been used for centuries to create distinctive Spanish and Portuguese torta-style cheeses with their characteristic creamy, sometimes runny, interiors. It is equally true for chymosin, the primary and most efficient enzyme found in traditional animal rennet, historically extracted from the stomachs of young ruminants.
A Spectrum of Coagulants: From Animal to Plant to Microbe
The world of rennet is diverse, reflecting centuries of cheesemaking ingenuity and adaptation:
-
Animal Rennet: Traditionally, animal rennet is sourced from the abomasum, the fourth stomach chamber of young, milk-fed ruminants such as calves, lambs, or kids. The primary enzyme responsible for coagulation in this rennet is chymosin, a remarkably predictable and efficient enzyme. Chymosin specifically targets and breaks down kappa-casein, a protein that stabilizes casein micelles in milk, allowing them to aggregate and form a curd. It does so with precise specificity, without initiating other undesirable chemical reactions that could compromise flavor or texture.
However, traditionally harvested animal rennet is rarely pure chymosin. It often contains varying amounts of pepsin, another enzyme also present in the abomasum. While chymosin is ideal, pepsin can continue to break down proteins in the developing cheese, leading to additional flavor development, which some cheesemakers desire for complex, aged cheeses, but others find introduces inconsistencies or off-notes. The presence of animal rennet also renders cheese unsuitable for vegetarian diets and can raise concerns for kosher or halal certifications, depending on the processing. -
Vegetable Rennet: As mentioned, certain plants produce enzymes capable of coagulating milk. The cardoon thistle is a prime example, lending unique characteristics to its cheeses. Other plant-derived coagulants exist, though they are less common in commercial cheesemaking due to variable activity and potential for bitter flavors.
-
Microbial Rennet: This category encompasses enzymes produced by specific fungi or molds, such as Rhizomucor miehei. These rennets are a popular vegetarian alternative to animal rennet, offering good coagulation properties and generally clean flavors, though their enzymatic activity can sometimes differ subtly from chymosin.
For most of the 20th century, rennet producers sought to refine animal rennet to isolate pure chymosin, chemically purifying it to remove the unwanted pepsin. While effective, this process was labor-intensive and expensive, making pure chymosin a premium ingredient, out of reach for many cheesemakers. The demand for a consistent, pure, and cost-effective chymosin set the stage for a groundbreaking scientific revolution.
A Leap in Biotechnology: The Birth of Fermentation-Produced Chymosin (FPC)
The turning point arrived in the mid-1970s, rooted in fundamental discoveries in molecular biology.

1973: Cohen and Boyer’s Breakthrough
The scientific landscape dramatically shifted in 1973 when American biochemists Stanley Cohen and Herbert Boyer conducted a pivotal experiment. They successfully created a small, circular piece of DNA called a plasmid, which they engineered to contain a gene for antibiotic resistance. Through a process known as transformation, they then forced this plasmid to be absorbed by E. coli bacteria. The modified bacteria, now carrying the foreign gene, were able to synthesize the protein responsible for antibiotic resistance, allowing them to survive and proliferate in the presence of antibiotics. This experiment marked the birth of recombinant DNA technology—the ability to combine DNA from different organisms—and laid the groundwork for modern genetic engineering.
1978/1982: Insulin as a Precedent for Precision Fermentation
Building upon Cohen and Boyer’s work, the biotechnology companies Genentech and Eli Lilly rapidly recognized the immense potential of this technology. In 1978, they employed recombinant DNA techniques to insert the human gene for insulin production into bacteria. These modified bacteria were then cultivated in large bioreactors, where they efficiently produced human insulin protein. This insulin was then precipitated out, purified, and made commercially available in 1982, revolutionizing diabetes treatment by providing a safe, abundant, and consistent supply of human insulin. This process, where microorganisms are engineered to produce specific compounds in a controlled environment, became known as precision fermentation.
1990: Pfizer and the Approval of FPC
It wasn’t long before this same innovative biotechnology was applied to the challenge of chymosin production. The pharmaceutical giant Pfizer adapted the precision fermentation technique to generate chymosin. They engineered microorganisms (typically bacteria or yeast) to carry the gene for calf chymosin. These modified microbes, grown in bioreactors, then churned out pure chymosin, identical in structure and function to the chymosin found in a calf’s stomach.
In a landmark decision in 1990, the FDA approved fermentation-produced chymosin (FPC) for use in cheesemaking. This approval was historic, marking the first time an ingredient produced using organisms with recombinant DNA was sanctioned for inclusion in the general food supply. Crucially, the FDA’s approval was based on extensive research demonstrating that, chemically, FPC is absolutely identical to animal-derived chymosin. The sole difference lies in the method of manufacturing: one is extracted from an animal, the other is produced by engineered microorganisms in a bioreactor. The final product itself is not a genetically modified organism; it is a purified enzyme.
Precision Fermentation: A Pillar of Modern Food and Medicine
The approval of FPC was not an isolated incident but a harbinger of a new era. Today, precision fermentation is a widely adopted and indispensable technology across our food and medicine systems, often without consumers realizing its pervasive influence.
This technology is used to produce a vast array of enzymes and other beneficial compounds found throughout food production. For example:
- Lactase for making lactose-free milk, enabling millions with lactose intolerance to enjoy dairy products.
- Amylase used in bread baking to improve dough consistency and crumb structure.
- Pectinase employed in orange juice production to clarify the juice and maximize yield.
- Essential vitamins like riboflavin (B2) and B-12, frequently added to fortified cereals and nutritional supplements.
- Specific amino acids crucial for balanced nutrition, often found in baby formula.
Beyond food, precision fermentation continues to be a cornerstone of pharmaceutical manufacturing. Medications such as GLP-1s (like Ozempic and Wegovy, used for diabetes and weight management) and Humulin (a brand of human insulin) are all products of this same biotechnology.
In every one of these instances—from FPC in cheese to essential vitamins and life-saving medications—the principle remains consistent: genetically modified bacteria or yeasts are employed at some stage during production to efficiently synthesize a desired compound. However, the final ingredient that reaches the consumer is a purified product (an enzyme, a vitamin, a hormone), not the genetically modified organism itself. Therefore, according to regulatory definitions, these ingredients are not considered "GMOs." This distinction is critical for understanding why cheese, made with FPC, can legitimately be labeled as GMO-free.
Navigating the Cheese Counter: Implications for Consumers and Cheesemakers
The introduction and widespread adoption of FPC have had profound implications for both the cheesemaking industry and consumers.
For Cheesemakers: Consistency, Cost, and Market Access
For cheesemakers, FPC offered a revolutionary solution to several long-standing challenges:
- Consistency and Predictability: Pure chymosin, free from pepsin, ensures a highly predictable coagulation process. This translates to more consistent curd formation, crucial for maintaining uniform quality, texture, and flavor profiles across batches, especially for large-scale producers.
- Cost-Effectiveness: Precision fermentation dramatically reduced the cost of obtaining pure chymosin compared to traditional purification methods from animal sources. This economic advantage made high-quality rennet more accessible and helped stabilize production costs.
- Vegetarian-Friendly Production: FPC provides an ideal solution for cheesemakers aiming to produce vegetarian-friendly cheeses. By using a non-animal source for their rennet, they can cater to a growing market segment driven by ethical, dietary, or religious considerations. This has allowed many traditional cheese styles to become available to a broader audience without compromising on quality or authenticity.
- Organic Certification: The status of FPC within organic standards can be nuanced. While the FDA does not classify FPC as a GMO ingredient, some organic certifying bodies or consumer interpretations may have stricter views on the use of any product derived from genetically engineered microorganisms. However, many major organic certifiers do permit FPC, recognizing that the final product is not a GMO and is chemically identical to natural chymosin. Cheesemakers must carefully navigate these certification requirements.
For Consumers: Informed Choices and the Perception Gap
For consumers, the story of FPC underscores the importance of informed understanding in an increasingly complex food system:
- Understanding Labels: The "vegetarian-friendly" label on cheese often indicates the use of FPC or microbial rennet, providing clear guidance for those avoiding animal products. However, the absence of a "GMO-free" label specifically addressing rennet (which is accurate, as the cheese is GMO-free) can lead to confusion if the underlying science isn’t understood.
- The Role of the Cheesemonger: This is where the expertise of individuals like Josh Windsor, with his background as an affineur and his engagement with community biology labs like Genspace, becomes invaluable. Cheesemongers serve as crucial educators, bridging the gap between scientific fact and consumer perception. They can explain the nuances of rennet, the regulatory definitions, and the benefits of FPC, empowering customers to make choices aligned with their values and understanding.
- Addressing Ethical and Environmental Concerns: For many, the concern about GMOs is intertwined with broader ethical considerations regarding animal welfare, industrial agriculture, and environmental impact. FPC, by providing a non-animal, highly efficient alternative, inadvertently addresses some of these concerns, offering a more sustainable and ethical pathway for cheesemaking.
The perception gap between the scientific definition of a GMO and public understanding remains a challenge. While regulators focus on the genetic modification of the food item itself, public concern often extends to any process involving genetic engineering. This article aims to clarify that distinction: while precision fermentation utilizes genetically engineered microorganisms, the purified chymosin enzyme itself is not a GMO.
The Future of Coagulation
As science and consumer preferences evolve, so too will the methods of cheesemaking. Research continues into new enzyme sources, more efficient coagulation methods, and even alternative milk proteins. However, the story of FPC serves as a powerful example of how biotechnology, when responsibly developed and rigorously tested, can provide solutions that benefit both producers and consumers, enhancing tradition while addressing modern demands for consistency, cost-effectiveness, and ethical production.
Josh Windsor’s unique perspective, nurtured through his daily work aging award-winning cheeses like Stockinghall Clothbound Cheddar and Greensward at Murray’s Cheese, and his explorations into the microbial world of cheese rinds at Genspace, embodies this confluence of tradition and innovation. His passion for understanding "how cheese ages" extends naturally to the molecular level, allowing him to illuminate the scientific truths behind the food we love.
In conclusion, the next time you approach the cheese counter, rest assured that the delicious wheels and wedges before you are free of GMOs. The conversation about rennet, however, offers a fascinating glimpse into the precision of modern science and its harmonious integration with the ancient art of cheesemaking, ensuring that our cheese remains both traditional in spirit and cutting-edge in production.
