Baltimore, MD – A groundbreaking investigative series by Civil Eats senior staff reporter and contributing editor Lisa Held has cast a stark light on the profound and often devastating consequences of federal program cancellations under the Trump administration’s USDA. Titled "Losing Ground," Held’s four-part exposé documents the true cost when initiatives designed to fortify regional food systems are abruptly dismantled, leaving a trail of financial instability, broken trust, and reduced access to healthy food for vulnerable communities across the nation.
Held, a seasoned journalist with a focus on agriculture and the food system, shared her findings in a recent interview with Amy O’Neill Houck of Eat, Drink, Think, a podcast from Edible Communities. Her reporting, drawing from dozens of interviews with farmers, regional food system program managers, and affected organizations, reveals a landscape where promising growth and vital connections have been severely curtailed, threatening the resilience and equity of America’s food supply.
The Abrupt Shift: A Timeline of Hope and Disruption
The story of "Losing Ground" begins not with the cancellations, but with a period of unprecedented federal investment in regional food systems, spurred by the lessons of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Pre-Pandemic Norms: Historically, federal agricultural policy has largely favored large-scale commodity farms, with billions of dollars directed towards staple crops and industrial agriculture. Support for small, diversified fruit and vegetable farms, or those focused on regional markets, remained comparatively minuscule.
COVID-19’s Revealing Fragility (2020-2021): The pandemic served as a stark wake-up call, exposing the inherent fragility of a highly centralized, industrialized food system. When major processing plants for meat, eggs, and other commodities faced shutdowns, grocery store shelves emptied, and supply chains buckled. This crisis underscored the urgent need for greater regional resilience—a "spoke and hub" model where local production and distribution could buffer against global shocks. This realization garnered rare bipartisan support for policies aimed at strengthening local food economies.
Biden Administration’s Investment (2021-2023): Responding to this newfound consensus, the Biden administration, through the USDA, initiated a significant infusion of funds into new programs. These initiatives, many designed with multi-year contracts, aimed to stabilize supply chains, create new markets for small farms, and improve food access. Key among them were:
- Local Food Purchase Assistance (LFPA) Program and Local Food for Schools: Designed to connect small farms with wholesale buyers like food banks and schools, ensuring fair prices for farmers and healthy, local food for communities in need.
- Partnerships for Climate-Smart Commodities: A program intended to fund projects promoting climate-friendly agricultural practices and collect crucial data.
- Regional Food Business Centers: Established as hubs to organize, connect, and support local food businesses, from farms to processors and community kitchens.
- Increasing Land and Capital Markets Access Program: Aimed at helping young and beginning farmers overcome barriers to accessing land and capital.
Farmers and organizations, encouraged by multi-year commitments and a clear policy direction, began to invest, scale up, and build critical infrastructure, believing they were on a stable path toward a more resilient future.

The Trump USDA’s Reversal (2024 onwards): The momentum, however, was abruptly halted with the change in administration. Despite previously authorized funding and existing contracts, the Trump USDA initiated widespread cancellations and policy reversals. Lisa Held notes, "While every new presidential administration makes policy changes that reflects its priorities, Trump in his second term is the first to throw out legal contracts that had already been signed." This unprecedented move plunged the nascent regional food system into chaos, undermining years of effort and investment.
The Tangible Costs: Supporting Data and Devastating Examples
Held’s "Losing Ground" series paints a vivid picture of the human and economic toll of these policy shifts, demonstrating how what appears as bureaucratic maneuvering translates into real-world hardship.
The LFPA Program: A Win-Win Lost:
The Local Food Purchase Assistance (LFPA) program was consistently highlighted by farmers as the most impactful and sorely missed initiative. Held’s reporting showed how LFPA bridged a critical gap, enabling small farms—which traditionally struggle to compete in consolidated wholesale markets—to access stable, high-volume buyers at fair prices.
- Stalled Growth and Financial Strain: An Illinois farmer, specializing in chickens, doubled his flock in the first year of LFPA, then again in the second, investing heavily in feed and housing infrastructure. The sudden cancellation left him with significant inventory and no guaranteed market, disrupting his entire growth trajectory. Similarly, a Wisconsin pig farmer faced a crisis when piglets born with the expectation of a food bank purchase suddenly had no buyer. Farmers, who had built their business plans around these multi-year contracts, were left with substantial losses and uncertainty.
- Erosion of Food Equity: The impact extended directly to food access for underserved communities. In upstate New York, a collective of small farms, including Rock Steady Farm and those within Choi Commons, had leveraged LFPA to triple their wholesale sales. They were providing "culturally relevant vegetables to communities in New York, to Chinese elders, these beautiful, vibrant vegetables that reminded them of home." With funding gone, their wholesale revenue plummeted, leaving them to focus on markets where customers could afford higher prices. As one farmer, Tiana Kennedy, poignantly stated, "We’re going to survive, but we’re not going to thrive. For one moment in time, it felt like we were getting a glimpse of what it might look like to succeed, and now that’s done."
- From Fresh to Spoiled: Held’s visit to Hunter Hill CSA in Pennsylvania and the Eastside Community Pantry illustrated this stark contrast. Farmer Dan Hunter, who once supplied fresh, local produce to the pantry, could no longer do so. Pantry staff, who previously received "fresh tomatoes, okra, lettuce from Dan and handing it out the same day," now had to rely on commodity produce donations from large supermarkets, often finding "strawberries had mold on them and the bananas were brown." This shift directly undermined efforts to provide nutritious food to those most in need. Held noted that for many small farmers, sales of just $30,000 to $100,000 through LFPA were "life-changing," demonstrating how relatively small federal investments yielded immense local impact.
Climate Smart Commodities and the Data Gap:
The Partnerships for Climate-Smart Commodities program, while ultimately retained in a re-envisioned form, suffered significant setbacks. The initial cancellation and subsequent reapplication process meant projects lost at least a year of implementation time, severely impacting their effectiveness. More critically, the invaluable data collection component—which mandated soil sampling and reporting to build a national repository on climate-smart practices—was eliminated. Robert Bonnie, a former USDA official, expressed devastation over this loss, recognizing its long-term implications for understanding and addressing climate change in agriculture.
Regional Food Business Centers: Disconnecting the Hubs:
These centers were envisioned as crucial organizers for regional food systems, providing mini-grants (e.g., $19,000-$30,000 for a meat producer to buy a new fridge or a vegetable farm to acquire a delivery truck) and developing strategic plans. Held was particularly struck by the passion of those running these centers and the tangible impact they had. A Zoom meeting where USDA officials informed center managers of the cancellations, refusing to take questions, became a powerful symbol of the emotional toll. Managers, defying instructions, unmuted themselves to share their grief and thank each other for the work, highlighting the deep personal investment in their communities. While some organizations are attempting to maintain networks through cooperative entities or state-level funding, the initial scale of impact is significantly diminished.
Legal Challenges and Uncertain Reinstatement:
The cancellation of multi-year contracts also triggered legal battles. The Increasing Land and Capital Markets Access Program, designed to assist young and beginning farmers, saw its cancellation challenged in court by groups like FarmStand. While a preliminary injunction has temporarily reinstated some grants, the legal outcomes remain mixed and the process has created prolonged uncertainty. Held emphasizes that even successful legal challenges often cannot fully mitigate the damage, as a year of lost planting, delayed infrastructure, and changed business plans can have lasting repercussions in farming.
The Funding Disparity: A Chasm of Support:
Held underscores the stark disparity in federal agricultural funding. While regional food programs like the business centers received around $400 million, a "tiny drop" in the overall USDA budget, Congress simultaneously authorized an additional $60 billion for commodity programs over the next decade. This highlights a fundamental imbalance in federal priorities, where the bulk of support continues to flow to industrial agriculture rather than the diversified, smaller-scale farms that underpin regional resilience.

The DEI Backlash:
A particularly insidious aspect of the cancellations was the targeting of grants based on "diversity, equity, and inclusion" (DEI) language. Held reported that many individual grants, especially those benefiting small, diversified fruit and vegetable farms, were canceled because their applications contained terms like "equity," "Black farmers," "young farmers," or "LGBTQ farmers." This was a direct reversal of the Biden administration’s explicit directive for applicants to demonstrate how their programs would achieve equity. This politically motivated crackdown disproportionately harmed underserved farming communities and further alienated those working towards a more inclusive food system.
Official Responses and the Erosion of Trust
The Trump USDA’s official stance on these cancellations, as described by Held, was characterized by a lack of direct engagement with Civil Eats and public statements that often framed the previous administration’s initiatives as wasteful or misdirected.
Declined Comment and Aggressive Rhetoric: The USDA declined interview requests and direct comments for Held’s series. However, Secretary of Agriculture Brooke Rollins and other officials have publicly defended the cuts. Their rhetoric frequently sought to blame the Biden administration, labeling programs like the Partnerships for Climate-Smart Commodities as "Biden era slush funds" or "waste." Rollins famously called the climate program "largely built to advance the green new scam at the benefit of NGOs, not American farmers."
Prioritizing a "Certain Kind of Farmer": Officials often stated a return to "focusing on farmers," which many interpreted as a veiled reference to prioritizing traditional, large-scale commodity producers over those engaged in regional, diversified, or equity-focused agriculture. This messaging, combined with the cancellation of grants based on DEI language, sent a clear signal about which farmers the administration intended to support.
Rebranding, Not Reinstating: While some programs, like the Climate-Smart Commodities, were eventually allowed to be re-applied for under new names (e.g., "advancing markets for agriculture program"), the underlying policy intent shifted from climate action to market development. Held points out that many projects remained largely similar in practice but were stripped of their climate-centric branding. This emphasis on semantics rather than substance, coupled with the lost time for reapplication, further fueled frustration.
The Loss of Trust: Perhaps the most enduring consequence highlighted by Held is the profound loss of trust in the USDA among farmers and food system organizations. Many expressed deep skepticism about applying for future federal grants, feeling that their efforts and investments could be arbitrarily undone by political shifts. The aggressive, dismissive tone from officials, combined with the cancellation of legally binding contracts, left many feeling devalued and disrespected. The National Young Farmers Coalition launched a "We Are American Farmers" social media campaign in response, asserting their legitimacy in the face of perceived government neglect.
Implications: A Setback for Resilience, Equity, and Climate Action
The cancellations and policy shifts under the Trump USDA carry far-reaching implications, extending beyond individual farms to the broader health and sustainability of the American food system.

Weakened Regional Resilience: The primary goal of these programs was to build a more robust and localized food infrastructure. Their dismantling weakens this nascent resilience, leaving the nation more vulnerable to future supply chain disruptions, whether from pandemics, climate events, or geopolitical instability. The "spoke and hub" model, which gained critical momentum during COVID, has been deliberately undermined.
Deepened Inequities in Food Access: The direct link between canceled programs and reduced access to fresh, healthy food for low-income and underserved communities is undeniable. When small farms lose their wholesale markets to food banks and schools, the default often reverts to less nutritious, commodity-based options for those who can least afford fresh produce. This exacerbates existing health disparities and food insecurity.
Stalled Economic Growth for Small Farms: Many small, diversified farms saw a genuine opportunity to scale and stabilize their operations through federal support. The cancellations have not only halted this growth but often forced them back to precarious pre-program conditions, losing investments and market opportunities. This makes it harder for young and beginning farmers, and those from historically marginalized groups, to enter and succeed in agriculture.
Retreat from Climate Action: The systematic scrubbing of climate change terminology and the de-prioritization of climate-focused initiatives represent a significant setback for agricultural sustainability. By abandoning data collection and shifting focus away from climate outcomes, the USDA has hindered the ability to understand and mitigate the impacts of climate change on farming, which are becoming increasingly severe. Corporations, which had begun to align with climate-friendly practices when politically advantageous, are now quietly retreating from their sustainability commitments without federal encouragement or accountability.
Erosion of Government Credibility: The arbitrary cancellation of multi-year contracts has severely damaged the credibility of federal agencies. It signals that government commitments are not reliable, making it difficult for stakeholders to plan, invest, and trust in future partnerships. This loss of trust will take significant time and effort to rebuild, regardless of future administrations.
The Path Forward: State-Level Action and Enduring Advocacy:
Looking ahead, Lisa Held sees a period of adaptation and uncertainty. Many farmers and food system advocates are "finding their footing again" and exploring alternatives to federal assistance. Notably, some states are stepping into the void: Minnesota has created its own version of regional food support, and California recently announced state funding to continue its LFPA program for another year. This suggests a potential shift towards decentralized solutions and increased state-level leadership in regional food system development.
The future of federal involvement remains unclear, especially given the ongoing political climate and the difficulty of passing a comprehensive Farm Bill with mandatory funding for these critical programs. Held’s reporting underscores that the impacts of these cancellations are not merely policy adjustments but profound disruptions to livelihoods, community well-being, and the long-term health of America’s food system. The "Losing Ground" series serves as a powerful call to attention, urging a reevaluation of priorities and a renewed commitment to building a more resilient, equitable, and sustainable food future.
