By Alana Pedalino, Culture Cheese Magazine
Published: November 2, 2026
Category: Entertaining 2026
As the crisp air of autumn gives way to the anticipation of the holiday season, hosts across the globe begin to envision gatherings filled with warmth, cheer, and, inevitably, delectable food. For many, the centerpiece of such occasions is often a meticulously curated cheese board—a tableau of flavors, textures, and aromas designed to delight and engage. Yet, assembling such a spread, let alone orchestrating an entire event, can be daunting.
Fear not, aspiring hosts and culinary enthusiasts. Culture Cheese Magazine has tapped into the wisdom of three leading figures in the cheese world—Andrea Machuca-Kirkland of The Culinary Underground in Los Angeles, Bill Reed of Pedestrian Wine & Cheese in Chattanooga, Tennessee, and Megan Vaughan of Vaughan Cheese Counter & Bar in North Beach, Maryland. These professionals, each a master in their own right, share invaluable tips and tricks, just in time to transform your holiday hosting from stressful to sublime. From the foundational principles of genuine hospitality to innovative cheese selections and savvy business strategies, their collective expertise promises to enrich your entertaining repertoire and deepen your appreciation for the world of cheese.
The Essence of Elevated Entertaining: A Deep Dive with Cheese Professionals
The foundation of any memorable gathering, especially during the holidays, extends far beyond the menu. It lies in the spirit of hospitality—a concept eloquently articulated and practiced by our three experts. Their insights reveal that true hospitality is about creating an environment where every guest feels cherished, understood, and utterly at ease, paving the way for the culinary delights to shine.
Cultivating Connection: The Art of Genuine Hospitality
For Andrea Machuca-Kirkland, a seasoned event host and the creative force behind The Culinary Underground in Los Angeles, meticulous planning is the first step toward effortless hospitality. "Plan out a month in advance—even two months in advance," she advises, emphasizing the importance of securing seasonal ingredients. "Always reach for seasonal ingredients that are abundant at the farmers’ market, then plan your menu from there." This foresight not only ensures peak flavor and freshness but also reduces last-minute stress, allowing the host to be present and engaged with their guests.

Beyond logistics, Andrea underscores the profound impact of community building. "Make guests feel like they’re home and welcome," she states. "Once they feel welcome and they love what’s being offered on a plate, they will continually come back. I have loyal guests that will come to my events and ask, ‘When’s your next one?’" This loyalty is a testament to the genuine connection fostered through an inviting and unpretentious approach. Even in challenging situations, Andrea champions this ethos: "Hospitality means being inviting and unpretentious to get people to eat more cheese. Never turn people down. I have dealt with difficult customers, but there are times when I’ve gotten somebody who was grouchy—who was not at first into the cheese—and I turned that grouchy look into a smile. Always try to be inviting, even in unlikely circumstances." Her philosophy highlights the transformative power of a warm welcome, even for the most skeptical palates.
Echoing this sentiment, Bill Reed, owner of Pedestrian Wine & Cheese in Chattanooga, Tennessee, distills hospitality down to a fundamental human need: "Hospitality means creating a welcoming experience where someone is seen. If you can nail that in some way during the time that you have to connect with them, they feel comfortable, they feel safe, and everything else will fall into place." For Bill, this philosophy is not just for special events but is embedded in the very fabric of his shop. "The ethos of the shop is to be hospitable first and then see how much customers want to learn. In a small wine and cheese shop, if you’re not the most hospitable place around, then it’s going to be easy to forget about you." He concludes succinctly, "Hospitality is how you make [customers] feel," underscoring its intangible yet powerful impact on customer loyalty and business success.
Megan Vaughan, from Vaughan Cheese Counter & Bar in North Beach, Maryland, further illuminates this concept, drawing on her extensive culinary background, including experience at the renowned Eleven Madison Park. For Megan, hospitality is about ensuring people "never feel like they’re not special or fancy enough to appreciate cheese, because it can feel overwhelming to walk into this space and be greeted with a wall of 90 cheeses." Her approach is rooted in empathy and a desire to demystify the gourmet world. "My culinary and hospitality background sets the foundation of pure joy of having someone walk in, getting to take care of them, and making them feel welcome." This dedication to genuine care has become a hallmark of her business. "I think that’s a thing that has set my business apart in the community—that people know us for providing genuine hospitality." Ultimately, Megan believes, "In the end, people want to feel heard and seen and loved and cared for and important. That’s the same everywhere." This universal truth forms the bedrock of exceptional hosting, whether in a private home or a bustling cheese counter.
Navigating the Cheese Board: Expert Selections and Pairings
Once the spirit of hospitality is established, the focus shifts to the stars of the show: the cheeses themselves. Our experts offer practical advice on introducing adventurous flavors and selecting show-stopping centerpiece cheeses that will leave a lasting impression.
Demystifying Blue Cheese: A Gateway to Bold Flavors
Blue cheeses, with their distinct pungency and often intimidating appearance, can be a hurdle for many guests. Andrea Machuca-Kirkland, however, has perfected the art of converting blue cheese skeptics into enthusiasts. Her secret lies in drawing parallels to familiar, beloved flavors. "A great entryway cheese would be Rogue River Blue, especially around the holidays," she suggests. This award-winning blue, celebrated for its unique flavors infused with pear brandy, presents a gentle introduction. Andrea’s tactic is ingenious: "You could ask them, ‘Do you like whiskey? Do you like brown butter? Vanilla sugar cookies?’ Usually, they say, ‘Yes, I like these things.’ Then offer a spoonful. If they like those notes, then they’ve got to like the cheese because that’s what it tastes like." This sensory association creates a bridge from the known to the unknown, making the leap less daunting.

For those ready to explore further, Andrea recommends a carefully curated progression. "Also, always start with an unctuous blue. Cambozola—I’ve gotten a lot of transformations from that." Cambozola, a German cheese that marries the creaminess of a Camembert with the delicate veining of a Gorgonzola, offers a milder, buttery blue experience. From there, she guides palates to "Saint Agur," a rich, creamy French blue with a more pronounced yet still accessible flavor. "If they really like Saint Agur, they can move on to a Stilton," she concludes, pointing to the classic English blue known for its complex, nutty, and fruity notes. This step-by-step approach empowers guests to gradually expand their blue cheese horizons, transforming apprehension into appreciation.
Centerpiece Cheeses: Selections for Memorable Gatherings
Beyond introducing the blues, selecting cheeses that command attention and offer versatile pairing opportunities is crucial for any holiday spread. Andrea shares her top picks for centerpiece cheeses that are both delicious and dynamic.
First on her list is "OG Goat," a delicate goat gouda that surprises with its nuanced flavor profile. "It’s a delicate goat gouda, but it has notes of butterscotch. It reminds me of Mexican cajeta, which is cooked caramel." Its inherent sweetness makes it incredibly versatile. "But it can go either way. I can take some sweet and hot pickled peppers, a thin-sliced butter crostini, and shave the OG Goat on. For a sweet pairing, add some strawberry fennel jam. It’s versatile." The ability of OG Goat to transition seamlessly between sweet and savory contexts makes it an ideal choice for a diverse holiday palate, offering unexpected depth and appeal.
Next, Andrea highlights "Blakesville’s Linedeline," a cheese she pairs with a homemade creation: "homemade Aleppo pumpkin butter." Her description of this accompaniment is mouth-watering: "I’ll take some Kabocha Japanese pumpkins, which are very fleshy, and once I cook them down, they get buttery. Then I add brown sugar, different spices, and Aleppo peppers and let it go low and slow for about an hour. It becomes so velvety." The Linedeline, likely a soft, perhaps bloomy-rind cheese, would find a perfect counterpoint in the creamy, subtly spiced sweetness of the pumpkin butter, creating a harmonious and comforting seasonal pairing.
Finally, Andrea recommends "mimolette with curried pistachios." Mimolette, a vibrant orange, hard French cheese with a distinctive nutty and fruity flavor, offers a striking visual and textural contrast. "You get the sweet notes from the cheese and then savory from pistachios," she explains. The curried pistachios introduce an exotic, aromatic crunch that elevates the entire experience, demonstrating how thoughtful pairings can transform individual ingredients into a symphony of flavors and sensations. These centerpiece selections not only offer exceptional taste but also provide talking points and encourage guests to explore diverse culinary combinations.

Innovation and Resilience: The Evolving Landscape of the Cheese Business
The cheese industry, like many sectors of the food world, has undergone significant transformation, particularly in recent years. Our experts are not just purveyors of fine cheese; they are also astute business owners who have embraced innovation and adaptability to thrive in a dynamic market.
Pedestrian Wine & Cheese: Crafting Cheese In-House
Bill Reed’s Pedestrian Wine & Cheese in Chattanooga stands out for its groundbreaking business model. In a move that truly sets his establishment apart, Bill has pioneered in-house cheesemaking, an endeavor that required navigating complex regulatory landscapes. "We are the first shop [in Tennessee] that sells liquor, wine, and beer to have an agriculture license and kitchen," he proudly states. This unique combination allows Bill to offer an unparalleled level of freshness and a deeply local experience.
In his dedicated kitchen, Bill transforms locally sourced whole milk into an array of fresh cheeses: "We make fresh cheeses like ricotta, mozzarella, stracciatella, and burrata." This hands-on approach not only provides exceptional products but also creates a unique educational opportunity for his customers. "I learned how at a butcher in Brooklyn, so I show people how to make the cheese, and then I’ll give them all the ingredients to go home and do it themselves." This experiential learning fosters a deeper connection to the food and empowers customers to replicate the craft at home.
The success of this initiative is evident in its popularity. "A lot of our events are focused on cheesemaking," Bill shares. "We do farmers’ markets once a month, and we sell out of mozzarella and ricotta within three hours. We also have a cheese club and one of the cheeses folks get is a fresh cheese that we make in-house." This direct engagement with the community, coupled with the unique product offering, has proven highly effective.
Bill explains the strategic thinking behind this ambitious venture: "The cheesemaking aspect is an extra that makes our shop a little different than most. We had to get certain licenses approved. The approvers were just scratching their head. Why would any liquor store want to make cheese?" His answer reveals a keen business acumen: "But if I’m at the farmers’ market and I’m not allowed to bring wine, I can bring cheese and then talk to people about wine after. It’s the connective thread of how we can do more than just sit still and hope people come into the shop." This "connective thread" allows Pedestrian Wine & Cheese to expand its reach, diversify its revenue streams, and build a vibrant community around both cheese and wine.

Vaughan Cheese Counter & Bar: Storytelling and Strategic Diversification
Megan Vaughan’s Vaughan Cheese Counter & Bar in North Beach, Maryland, exemplifies another facet of innovation: deep connection to producers and strategic business diversification. Megan’s approach is deeply personal and rooted in storytelling. "I work with all of the farms directly, so I get to know them and tell their stories to my customers through the cheese," she explains. This direct relationship not only ensures the quality and provenance of her products but also enriches the customer experience. Her counter boasts an impressive selection, "between 75 and 95 cheeses that rotate seasonally—all US cheeses, with just a few exceptions." Each cheese comes with a narrative, connecting customers to the land and the hands that crafted it.
This commitment to storytelling extends to every customer interaction, even for online orders. "[When we ship cheese,] our boxes always have a handwritten card from me thanking them for their order, plus an index card full of descriptions of every cheese in that box that say, ‘This is the name of the cheese. This is what it tastes like. This is where it’s from. This is a fun fact about it.’" This personal touch transforms a simple purchase into an educational and memorable experience, reinforcing the bond between the customer and the product.
Beyond her curatorial excellence, Megan has proactively designed her business for resilience, particularly in the wake of global disruptions. "When designing the business, it was important that it was designed in a way that feels COVID-proof—that if any one thing got decimated, the business could continue running." This forward-thinking approach led to significant adaptations. "I redid online retail post-COVID, and I’ve since been developing classes to diversify." Her philosophy is one of constant evolution: "It’s really important that as we are looking down the throat of massive change industry-wide, that nothing can feel too precious. You need to be able to change on a dime, and we learned that. I’m seeing it with farms, as well. To be a smart businessperson, you need to have a diverse set of what you do. And it also makes it more fun." Megan’s strategic diversification—from online sales to educational classes—ensures not only business continuity but also sustained engagement and growth in a rapidly changing market.
The Broader Implications: Elevating the Cheese Experience
The collective wisdom shared by Andrea, Bill, and Megan offers profound implications, not just for holiday entertaining but for anyone seeking to deepen their relationship with food and community. Their insights provide a roadmap for elevating the cheese experience, whether you’re a home host or a seasoned professional.
For the Home Host: Embracing Confidence and Creativity
For those planning holiday gatherings, the primary takeaway is empowerment. Andrea’s emphasis on advance planning and seasonal ingredients provides a practical framework for reducing stress and ensuring quality. Her approachable method for introducing blue cheeses, by linking them to familiar flavors, offers a tangible strategy for expanding guests’ palates and fostering culinary adventure. The specific centerpiece cheese suggestions—OG Goat, Blakesville’s Linedeline, and Mimolette—along with their imaginative pairings, unlock new levels of creativity, allowing hosts to craft truly unique and memorable cheese boards that go beyond the expected. Ultimately, the lessons in genuine hospitality from all three experts remind hosts that the emotional connection forged with guests is as vital as the food itself, transforming a meal into an experience of shared joy and belonging.

For the Industry Professional: Models for Success and Resilience
For professionals within the cheese and broader culinary industries, these insights offer invaluable models for success in a competitive and evolving market. Bill Reed’s pioneering spirit in integrating cheesemaking into a retail environment demonstrates the power of vertical integration and experiential marketing. His "connective thread" strategy, using cheese to bridge to other offerings like wine, provides a blueprint for diversified customer engagement and market expansion. Megan Vaughan’s dedication to direct farm relationships and storytelling highlights the increasing consumer demand for transparency and narrative in their food choices. Her proactive "COVID-proof" business design and philosophy of constant adaptation underscore the critical importance of resilience, innovation, and diversification in navigating industry shifts. These professionals exemplify how authenticity, education, and a willingness to embrace change can cultivate loyal customer bases and ensure long-term viability.
The Future of the Cheese Industry: Connection and Community
The overarching implication is a hopeful vision for the future of the cheese industry—one rooted in connection, community, and genuine passion. From Andrea’s focus on making guests feel "home and welcome" to Bill’s desire for customers to feel "seen," and Megan’s commitment to ensuring everyone feels "heard and seen and loved and cared for," a clear thread emerges: the human element is paramount. In an age of increasing digital interaction, these professionals remind us that the tactile, sensory experience of sharing cheese, coupled with authentic human connection, remains irreplaceable. By prioritizing hospitality, demystifying complex flavors, embracing innovation, and telling the stories behind the food, the cheese industry can continue to thrive, enriching lives one delicious bite and heartfelt interaction at a time.
As the holiday season draws near, let these expert voices inspire you. Whether you’re selecting a bold blue, crafting a seasonal pairing, or simply opening your home, remember that the most exquisite ingredient is always genuine hospitality. With these tips from the pros, your holiday gatherings are poised to be truly unforgettable.
