By Suzanne Podhaizer
November 16, 2026
Web Exclusive
A Legacy at Risk: David Ducharme’s Retirement and the Future of Spruce-Wrapped Cheeses
Greensboro, Vermont – In the serene, snow-dusted landscape of Vermont’s Northeast Kingdom, a quiet crisis is unfolding that threatens to alter the very essence of some of America’s most celebrated artisan cheeses. David Ducharme, a man whose hands have skillfully coaxed the living essence from spruce trees for over a decade, is retiring this fall. With no apparent successor to master his unique craft, Ducharme may well be the last American artisan in his field, leaving a void that could force cheesemakers to abandon a beloved tradition of local sourcing.
This impending departure casts a long shadow over the future of iconic cheeses like Winnimere from Jasper Hill Farm, a washed-rind masterpiece that recently secured its second "Best of Show" title at the 2026 American Cheese Society Judging & Competition, an honor it first claimed in 2013. Winnimere, with its lush, pudding-like texture and complex flavors reminiscent of a campfire in a conifer forest, owes much of its distinctive character and structural integrity to the spruce cambium strips that encircle each round. These bands, sourced locally by Ducharme, are more than mere packaging; they are an integral ingredient, a direct link to the very landscape that inspires the cheese.
The potential loss of Ducharme’s unique skill highlights a broader vulnerability within the artisanal food movement: the fragility of specialized, often labor-intensive, local supply chains. As cheesemakers and enthusiasts grapple with this looming reality, the question isn’t just about finding a replacement for a material, but about preserving an irreplaceable connection to place, craft, and the dwindling pool of artisans who embody them.
A Chronology of Craft and Concern
The story of Winnimere, and indeed many spruce-wrapped cheeses, is deeply intertwined with the rhythms of nature and the ingenuity of human hands.
Early Inspirations (Pre-2000s): The tradition of wrapping soft, washed-rind cheeses in spruce bark originates in the Jura Mountains of France and Switzerland. Cheeses like Försterkäse and the revered Mont d’Or (Vacherin Mont d’Or) are historically bound by strips of spruce cambium, which prevent them from oozing as they ripen and impart a distinct resinous, woody aroma and flavor. This age-old practice served both a practical purpose and contributed significantly to the sensory profile of the cheese.
Jasper Hill Farm’s Vision (Mid-2000s): Brothers Mateo and Andy Kehler, founders of Jasper Hill Farm and Cellars, embarked on a mission to create cheeses that profoundly reflected Vermont’s unique terroir. Inspired by European traditions, they envisioned a raw-milk winter cheese that would capture the essence of their "working landscape – a marriage of the farm and the forest." Winnimere was born from this vision, designed to be wrapped in local spruce, grounding it firmly in its Vermont origins.
The Arrival of David Ducharme (Circa 2010s): The critical challenge for Jasper Hill was finding someone capable of sustainably and consistently producing the spruce cambium strips. This is where David Ducharme entered the scene. For over a decade, Ducharme, based in Greensboro, became the indispensable link between the Vermont forest and Jasper Hill’s cheese caves. His expertise allowed Winnimere to truly embody its local narrative.

Ducharme’s Ingenious Process: Unlike the traditional European "sanglières" who must rapidly strip bark from freshly felled trees due to insect infestations, Ducharme developed a revolutionary, patented process. He can harvest spruce logs in the fall and early winter, then stockpile them at his mill. The key to his innovation lies in a custom-built pressure cooker. Steaming the logs softens the lignin, allowing him to peel off the inner bark in large, intact sheets, which he then precisely cuts into 1-inch strips. This method not only extended the working window but also demonstrated a level of ingenuity that reportedly "stunned French sanglières" when they visited Vermont.
Uplands Cheese’s Parallel Journey (Mid-2000s onwards): In Wisconsin, co-owner and head cheesemaker Andy Hatch of Uplands Cheese faced a similar challenge for his acclaimed Rush Creek Reserve, another spruce-wrapped cheese inspired by Mont d’Or. After years of trying to source local cambium, working with the US Department of Agriculture Forest Service Forest Products Laboratory, Hatch concluded, "We just couldn’t find the right trees, the right people, the right equipment to produce it locally." Ultimately, Uplands Cheese turned to importing bark from famed French sanglière Marie Faivre, a product Hatch describes as "wonderful."
The Looming Retirement (Fall 2026): With Ducharme’s decision to retire after this fall’s production, Jasper Hill Farm is now in a frantic race against time. They are currently "stockpiling as many of Ducharme’s spruce cambium strips as he can possibly cut," as Mateo Kehler confirms, hoping to bridge the gap until, ideally, a successor can be found. The immediate future of Winnimere’s local identity hinges on this limited supply and the desperate search for a new artisan.
Supporting Data: The Science and Art of the Spruce Band
The spruce cambium band is far more than an aesthetic flourish; it plays a crucial role in the development and character of cheeses like Winnimere and Rush Creek Reserve.
The Biology of the Cambium: Located between a tree’s exterior bark and its woody core, the cambium is a thin, dynamic layer of cells. These cells divide rapidly in spring and more slowly in summer, producing new wood on the inside and new bark on the outside, contributing to the tree’s radial growth. The "inner bark," which includes the cambium layer, is the material of choice for cheese wrapping.
Functional Importance:
- Structural Support: For soft, runny cheeses, the spruce band acts as a natural corset, preventing the cheese from collapsing or oozing excessively as it ripens. This allows for a longer, more controlled aging process, developing complex flavors and a unique texture.
- Flavor and Aroma Contribution: The volatile compounds present in the spruce cambium slowly migrate into the cheese over weeks of aging, imparting distinct notes of pine, resin, and earth. This contribution is essential to the "campfire in a forest of conifers" tasting notes often associated with Winnimere.
- Microbial Influence: The bark itself can carry indigenous microorganisms from the forest environment. While cheesemakers often inoculate the strips with specific ripening cultures, the natural flora from the spruce can also play a subtle role in the microbial ecosystem of the cheese’s rind, further linking it to its natural origin.
Ducharme’s Innovation in Detail: His process is a testament to Yankee ingenuity. The laborious initial step of using a drawknife to remove the rough outer bark is physically demanding, requiring strength and precision. The custom-built pressure cooker, designed by Ducharme himself, is the true game-changer. By softening the lignin – a complex polymer that provides structural rigidity to plant cell walls – the inner bark can be peeled in a single, continuous sheet. This not only makes the process more efficient but also yields strips of consistent quality and size, critical for artisan cheesemaking. This departure from the European method, necessitated by different forestry practices and pest concerns, underscores Ducharme’s unique contribution.
Economic Realities and Tariffs: The challenges faced by Uplands Cheese in sourcing local cambium highlight the economic difficulties. Even with dedicated research and collaboration with government agencies, finding the "right trees, the right people, the right equipment" proved insurmountable in Wisconsin. This forced them to import, a decision that, while yielding "wonderful bark," has become more costly due to recent tariffs. This demonstrates how global trade policies can directly impact the cost and accessibility of niche artisanal ingredients, even when an intention to source locally exists.

Official Responses and the Search for a Successor
The news of David Ducharme’s retirement has elicited a mix of admiration, concern, and a determined effort to find a path forward from those directly affected.
Mateo Kehler, Co-Owner, Jasper Hill Farm: Kehler is unequivocal about the significance of Ducharme’s work and the potential impact of his retirement. "Our working landscape is a marriage of the farm and the forest," he reiterates, emphasizing how Ducharme’s spruce strips make Winnimere "truly reflective of this place, this landscape." The idea of importing bark from France, while a necessary stopgap, is not a preferred long-term solution. "The goal has always been to build a resilient local economy," Kehler states, articulating the philosophical core of Jasper Hill’s operation. He laments the broader economic forces at play: "Forces far beyond our control, and federal trade policy… [have] decimated our working forests. The mills are all gone." For Kehler, Ducharme’s situation is a symptom of this larger decline, leading to a profound sense of loss.
Andy Hatch, Co-Owner and Head Cheesemaker, Uplands Cheese: Hatch’s experience underscores the difficulty of Ducharme’s unique position. His years of unsuccessful attempts to source local spruce for Rush Creek Reserve speak volumes about the specialized knowledge and infrastructure required. While he praises the quality of imported French bark from Marie Faivre, the practical and economic pressures of tariffs make a strong case for the desirability of a local source, if one were available. His story reinforces the idea that Ducharme’s skill is not easily replicated.
David Ducharme, Artisan Spruce Stripper: While Ducharme’s direct quotes on his retirement are not extensively detailed in the original article, his hopes for a successor offer insight into his perspective. He acknowledges the job is "strenuous, and sometimes lonely." Yet, he holds out hope that "somebody will come along who has a ‘love of the working landscape and appreciation for… the small things,’ and who is willing to learn the art of ‘reading the log’ as they work." This phrase, "reading the log," encapsulates the deep intuitive knowledge and nuanced understanding required for his craft – skills that cannot be taught from a manual alone. He firmly believes that using French cambium "will change Winnimere’s flavor," and "even more crucially, it will change the cheese’s story."
The immediate official response from Jasper Hill is to maximize Ducharme’s final production and actively seek a new artisan. However, the search has thus far yielded no viable candidates, highlighting the severe challenge in finding someone with the dedication, physical aptitude, and specialized knowledge to take on this unique role.
Implications: Flavor, Story, and the Future of Artisanal Craft
The potential disappearance of David Ducharme’s craft carries multifaceted implications, extending beyond the mere availability of spruce strips to the very identity and philosophy of American artisan cheesemaking.
Impact on Flavor Profile: Ducharme’s assertion that French cambium will alter Winnimere’s flavor is not a trivial point. Terroir, the concept that a food’s flavor is influenced by its environment, is central to artisan production. The specific species of spruce, the soil conditions, the microclimate of Vermont’s forests—all contribute to the unique chemical compounds within the cambium. Substituting this with bark from the Jura region, even if excellent, would introduce different subtle aromatic and phenolic compounds, subtly shifting the cheese’s complex taste profile. For a cheese like Winnimere, celebrated for its hyper-local expression, this is a significant alteration.
The Erosion of "Story" and Authenticity: Perhaps even more profound is the impact on the cheese’s narrative. As Kehler articulates, the "goal has always been to build a resilient local economy." Winnimere’s story is one of integrated local sourcing: milk from Vermont cows, aged in Vermont cellars, wrapped in Vermont spruce. Importing bark breaks this chain, weakening the cheese’s claim as a true product of its specific Vermont landscape. In an increasingly globalized food market, the authenticity of a product’s story and its connection to place are powerful differentiators and sources of value for consumers.

A Broader Crisis of Artisanal Skills: Ducharme’s situation is not an isolated incident but a poignant example of a wider phenomenon: the decline of specialized artisanal crafts. Many traditional skills, often labor-intensive, physically demanding, and requiring years of apprenticeship and intuitive knowledge, struggle to find successors in modern economies. Younger generations may be less inclined towards such demanding work, or the economic viability of these niche crafts may not compete with other opportunities. The "art of reading the log" – a phrase that suggests a deep, almost symbiotic understanding of the material – is difficult to transfer and may not fit neatly into formal educational structures.
Economic Resilience and Local Supply Chains: The challenges faced by Jasper Hill and Uplands Cheese underscore the fragility of local supply chains. While the ideal of a "resilient local economy" is powerful, it requires a robust network of supporting industries and skilled artisans. When elements of this network disappear, like local mills or specialized craftspeople, the entire system is weakened, often forcing producers to turn to larger, more distant, and sometimes less sustainable, sources. Tariffs, as seen with Uplands Cheese, can further complicate these global sourcing decisions, adding cost and uncertainty.
The "Grief" as an Ingredient: Mateo Kehler’s poignant observation, "There’s a certain nostalgia, or maybe grief. That may be the main ingredient in our cheese," speaks volumes. It encapsulates the emotional weight of witnessing the erosion of traditions, local industries, and the intimate connections between people, land, and craft. This "grief" becomes a bittersweet flavor, an unspoken element in the cheese, representing not just what is present, but what is slowly being lost.
Conclusion: A Call for Preservation
David Ducharme’s retirement marks a critical juncture for American artisan cheesemaking. His unique skill in producing spruce cambium strips has been a cornerstone of local identity for acclaimed cheeses like Winnimere, embodying a deep connection between farm, forest, and craft. As Jasper Hill Farm frantically searches for a successor, the broader implications of Ducharme’s departure resonate far beyond Greensboro, Vermont.
This situation serves as a stark reminder of the fragility of specialized artisanal crafts and the intricate, often unseen, networks that sustain local food economies. It challenges us to consider what is truly lost when such skills disappear – not just an ingredient, but a part of a cheese’s flavor, its story, and the very cultural fabric of a region. The "grief" that Kehler speaks of is a call to action, urging a renewed appreciation for the "small things" and the dedicated artisans who, through their hands and ingenuity, imbue our food with authenticity, character, and a profound sense of place. The future of America’s iconic spruce-wrapped cheeses, and perhaps a piece of its artisanal soul, hangs in the balance.
